Understanding Article 3

Article 3 of GDPR defines its territorial scope. Unlike previous EU data protection law, GDPR has significant extraterritorial reach, applying to organizations worldwide under certain conditions.

GDPR applies through two main criteria:

  1. Establishment criterion (Article 3(1)): Processing in the context of EU establishment
  2. Targeting criterion (Article 3(2)): Processing of EU data subjects' data by non-EU organizations

Establishment Criterion (Article 3(1))

GDPR applies to processing of personal data in the context of the activities of an establishment in the EU, regardless of whether the processing takes place in the EU.

What Constitutes an Establishment?

  • Any real and effective activity through stable arrangements
  • Branch offices, subsidiaries, or representatives
  • A single employee can constitute establishment
  • Legal form is not determinative

Key Points

  • Location of processing is irrelevant if establishment exists
  • Processing must be "in the context of" the establishment's activities
  • Even if data is processed entirely outside EU, GDPR applies

Targeting Criterion (Article 3(2)(a))

GDPR applies to non-EU organizations processing EU data subjects' data when offering goods or services to them.

Indicators of Targeting EU Data Subjects

  • Use of EU language (other than English)
  • Use of EU currency (EUR)
  • Mention of EU customers or users
  • EU-specific top-level domain (.de, .fr, .eu)
  • Delivery to EU addresses
  • Dedicated EU support or contact details
  • Advertising targeted at EU audiences
Note

Mere accessibility of a website from the EU is not sufficient. There must be evidence of intention to offer goods or services to EU data subjects.

Monitoring Criterion (Article 3(2)(b))

GDPR applies to non-EU organizations monitoring the behavior of EU data subjects, where that behavior takes place in the EU.

Examples of Monitoring

  • Tracking individuals on the internet (cookies, device fingerprinting)
  • Profiling for targeted advertising
  • Behavioral analytics
  • Location tracking
  • Building profiles for credit scoring
  • Health monitoring via wearables

Quick Decision Tree

Use this decision tree to determine if GDPR applies to your organization:

Step 1: Do you have an establishment in the EU?

  • Yes: GDPR applies to processing in the context of that establishment
  • No: Proceed to Step 2

Step 2: Do you offer goods or services to EU data subjects?

  • Yes (free or paid): GDPR applies
  • No: Proceed to Step 3

Step 3: Do you monitor behavior of EU data subjects (occurring in EU)?

  • Yes: GDPR applies
  • No: GDPR does not apply

Practical Examples

ScenarioGDPR Applies?Reason
US company with EU subsidiaryYesEstablishment criterion
Indian IT company processing EU employee data for EU clientYesProcessor for EU controller
Australian e-commerce site shipping to GermanyYesOffering goods to EU
US SaaS with EU pricing in EURYesTargeting EU market
Japanese app tracking EU user behaviorYesMonitoring criterion
US blog accessible from EU but not targeting EUNoMere accessibility insufficient
Brazilian company with only Brazilian customersNoNo EU nexus

EU Representative Requirement

Organizations subject to GDPR under Article 3(2) must appoint an EU representative unless:

  • Processing is occasional
  • Processing does not include large-scale special category data or criminal data
  • Processing is unlikely to result in risk to data subjects

EU Representative Responsibilities

  • Point of contact for supervisory authorities
  • Point of contact for data subjects
  • Must be established in an EU member state where data subjects are located
  • Can be held liable for non-compliance